Signs American Idol’s Carrie Underwood‘s Relationship With Her Costars Is Strained (The Other Judges Aren’t Happy With The Latest Addition)
While American Idol’s latest judge, Carrie Underwood, seems to have the best intentions, the country superstar has received public backlash for overly lenient critiques. The star joined in the spring of 2025, replacing the long-running Katy Perry. Katy was a panelist in the singing competition for an impressive six seasons. While Katy was heavily scrutinized for her more direct style of feedback, Carrie has been met with similar criticism. However, this time, it seems like the judge has fallen on the other end of the spectrum.
Carrie’s debut on American Idol season 23 has been rocky at best. Many feel that the star has been too hesitant when offering constructive criticism. Although Carrie has been offered a multi-year contract, the show may consider breaking this contract if viewership plunges. It seems that the other panelists, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, aren’t impressed with her performances either, as her co-stars have publicly spoken about her questionable judging style. If Carrie doesn’t get her act together, the star may face some serious consequences.
Carrie’s Judging Style Has Been Harshly Critiqued
Carrie Hasn’t Offered Constructive Criticism
Audiences were excited to see Carrie return to the singing competition as the show aided in her “big break” back in 2005. While her involvement was generally well-received, Carrie’s American Idol season 23 stint’s disappointing many viewers. It seems as though Katy’s replacement is too good-natured to turn anyone away. Carrie is faced with a difficult decision when eliminating talented individuals, but these choices are necessary in this role.
Related
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Carrie’s intentions seem pure. She has gone out of her way to ensure that all contestants feel welcomed, comfortable, and appreciated. This was especially evident when one contestant, Breanna Nix, entered with her husband and son. Carrie rushed to hold the toddler so that Breanna could focus on her performance. When the contestant implied that her role as a stay-at-home mother was unimportant, Carrie ensured that Breanna received proper credit, saying,
“Never say ‘I’m just a stay-at-home mom.’ You have the most important job.”
This decision was admirable. Carrie validated Breanna’s position in the household while ensuring that this artist could perform to the best of her ability. Carrie’s position as a judge is undeniably important. Her charm and charisma have boosted the contestants’ comfort in a highly stressful environment. However, the star has struggled to bring down the hammer when it is necessary. Carrie’s decision to eliminate contestants is just as important.
Luke & Lionel Aren’t Impressed
Carrie Can’t Say No
Carrie’s costars, Luke and Lionel, have identified this major flaw in Carrie’s judging. The stars spoke on The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon, with regard to the latest season and their latest addition. The superstars playfully poked fun at Carrie’s challenges, but there seemed to be some lingering frustrations.
Luke and Lionel have been panelists on American Idol for the last seven seasons.
Carrie’s counterparts have extensive experience on the show. They understand that saying “no” to contestants is as, if not more, important than sparing their feelings. Lionel mimicked her feedback for the first few contestants, saying,
“The first contestant? ‘Yes. Go through.’ Second contestant. ‘Yes. Go through.’ Third contestant…Ohhh. And Luke and I would laugh and were like, we go, ‘Well, she’s got to say no.’ She said, ‘Well, she’s so cute. She’s so adorable.’ The answer is no!”
Carrie defended herself from this playful banter, implying that, because she got her first start on the show, she felt compelled to dig deeper and ask, “Is there more in there?” Without hesitation, Lionel responded, “There wasn’t any more in that one particular. It was firm. It was no.” While her co-stars delivered these comments lightheartedly, there was truth in their feedback. Carrie is hindering the process by accepting every singer.
Will Carrie Last On American Idol?
Carrie Has So Much Potential
Carrie’s introduction hasn’t received a positive reception, with some insiders questioning how long she may last. RadarOnline reports that one industry insider claimed that she’s “too nice for the job” and “her presence is making for dull TV.” Many feel that Carrie could be actively impairing the other judges’ decisions. Things don’t seem very promising at the moment, but Carrie has so much more to contribute than she’s credited for.
Carrie is an incredibly talented and empathetic individual. Her genuine love for the industry and her compassion for contestants have fostered a welcoming environment. She has the potential to be one of American Idol’s best judges. However, she may have to prove herself first. As difficult as it is, Carrie is going to have to take harder stances. She may discover that sometimes saying “no” is the best thing you can do for a growing artist.
American Idol airs Sundays at 8 p.m. EDT on ABC.
Sources: RadarOnline, The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon/YouTube
